top of page

The Optimist

Writer: Allen Crater
Allen Crater
5 hours ago
10 min read
Snowy burned forest at sunrise, with a camouflaged hunter in orange sitting among dead trees.

Morning's first dim glow silhouettes the spine of jagged, white-faced peaks that rise in the east. I shuffle my feet to stave off the creeping cold that always seems most bitter just before daybreak and bring the 12s back up, scanning south-facing slopes where mid-day rays have licked away some of the snow.


I begin from the left, easing my glass slowly across. A patch of pines breaks the monotony of brown rocks. I scan past. More rocks. Then, in the grey, liminal light, I register a blotch of blonde that doesn't quite match. A momentary pause to adjust the focus. The shape goes fuzzy then morphs into a cervid; not just any cervid, a big, blocky cervid who looks to be wearing a small tree on his head. He sports a thick, nearly black mane, dark legs, and wide-framed, chocolate-brown antlers polished white at the tips.


Hunter in orange vest kneels beside a dead elk with large antlers in a burned forest under a bright blue sky.

My heart jumps. It's a hell of a sight for a whitetail- chasing flatlander who has yet to notch a tag on an elk. Even at 1,200 yards this bull seems impossibly close. I know it's not true, but I pull down the binos because it feels like he's staring right through me.


And it turns out my protagonist is not alone. As the sun slowly washes over the hillside, five more bulls, any of which I would gladly claim as my first, emerge from shadows – where seconds before there was nothing. How, I wonder, can an animal so damn big vanish and reappear like some hustler's slick sleight of hand?


It's the first full day of our hunt and we're tucked tight on a glassing knob, seven backcountry miles from the truck, overlooking an old burn. Where just two weeks ago Kyle, the oldest of my two sons, helped his buddy take his first bull, a solid 6x6 – one of several they'd spotted on opening weekend of firearms season.


It seems a few have decided to stick around, just like we'd hoped. So far things are coming together – I'm optimistic.


This western hunt, which has become an annual tradition, marks my fifth with both boys – our third chasing elk together – and I'm the only one that has yet to find wapiti success. But this time, I'm confident, will be different, and the glowing hillside crisscrossed with feeding bulls bolsters my conviction.


Hunter kneels beside a downed elk in a pine forest, holding its antlers; a compound bow lies in the foreground.

Two days ago Blake and I hopped a plane from Michigan to meet up with Kyle in the Big Sky state he now calls home – general-season licenses burning holes in our camo pockets after the long wait. Kyle, who already tagged his bull with a bow, had spent the last four months scouting locations and laying plans. He would assume the role of defacto guide for me and his younger brother on this DIY, public-land adventure.


Kyle spent his college years here in Montana, moved home to Michigan for his first job, met his wife, and then somehow convinced her to move back. It's hard to get this place out of your blood if, like him, your fire burns for hunting, fly angling, and a life spent out-of-doors in big, wild places. Now they are expecting their first child. It's hard to get my mind around how quickly the time has passed. That it's been over two decades since these two grown men tagged behind me in oversized camo through the Michigan woods. That soon I might get to do it all again with grandkids.


We'd made the winding drive over passes and through conifer-crossed valleys to the trailhead, then hiked six miles through dense deadfall with overloaded packs to set spike camp. Spending the last of the daylight glassing nearby, we'd spotting one lone bull about a mile off, before retiring to the relative warmth of our tipi and the comforting calories of dehydrated dinners (and a Snickers bar I had secretly stashed away).


A bunter with backpack climbs over thick deadfall in an old burn in the mountains

The alarm on my phone buzzed early the next morning. Still tangled in my sleeping bag, I'd scooted over to the small stove to rekindle logs and boil water for coffee. Sufficiently caffeinated, we'd dressed in the brief warmth, optimistically loaded our packs and rifles, clicked on our headlamps, and began the mile-long climb through deep snow and endless blowdowns – boots crunching over the crusty surface before breaking through with each step. Near the first rise we'd extinguished the lights and continued by moonlight up and over, then down, before one last big climb to our post.


I was pulling ragged breaths from the effort when we'd finally reached the top – dripping sweat from my cap despite the low mercury. But the breeze quickly cooled my perspiration, so I'd added puffy layers before settling in behind the glass, waiting for daylight to catch up.


A hunter sits in the snow glassing distant wooded hillsides

And now here we are, watching six bulls wander in and out of cover, munching grass like it might be their last meal. We have a decision to make: do we try to make a move now, or wait for them to bed and set up for the evening? Between our perch and theirs lies a shallow valley, then a small rise, followed by another drop and the taller hillside they occupy.


Our mapping tool says it's about 500 yards to the closer knob – still nearly a 700-yard shot – outside of our effective range. Alternatively, we could drop down far to the left, make a big loop, and attempt to come up the backside. We talk it over. Despite my eagerness to get into action, forcing the issue seems like an unnecessary risk. The bachelor bulls are undisturbed and lazily feeding; let's wait for them to bed, get into a better spot, and then play our cards when they get back on their feet. It's still early in the hunt; time is on our side. The boys both agree.


We watch as the last of them gradually drop over the back into the dark timber, glass for another couple hours, replenish with snacks, then make our move. Down the first valley, up the small rise, down again, over the skinny creek, and then up the steep hill to a spot we named "the rock pile." From here, if they follow the script, we'll have shots anywhere from 100 to 500 yards – a much more comfortable range.


A hunter with backpack stands near a large burned tree on a hillside in Montana

The way the rock pile lays out, we need to split up to see both directions. I set up on the near side overlooking a small saddle to the west where two of the bulls fed this morning. My shots will be close – all less than 200 yards. Kyle and Blake scramble over the top and scan the east where the other four bulls were spotted. From here they can cover the saddle on that side all the way to the top of the ridge about 500 yards off.


Now the waiting game begins. Our setup is ideal – we've taken our time getting into a position that offers solid visibility and multiple shot options, we have great cover, and the wind is favorable. It's about 1:30, a few hours before we expect the bulls to feed out. I throw on my warm layers, wedge myself into the rocks, and begin to scan the terrain. The afternoon rays land warm on my face and the scent of evergreen hangs heavy in the November air. It reminds me of the Christmas trees we used to cut for the holidays as a kid.


Suddenly a shots cracks, shattering the silence and startling my resting chin from my chest. I must have dozed off. I'm momentarily disoriented. Shit! How long have I been out? I check my watch: 2:30 – much earlier than I anticipated any action. It had to be Blake; we haven't seen another hunter or crossed another set of prints. I wait for the follow-up shot but it never comes, so I slowly climb up and poke my head over the top. I can see the boys standing together and Blake has the shakes.

I want to shout, but gather myself and go slow – creeping my way over, staying low. Kyle confirms – after watching three bulls for close to 15 minutes Blake was able to get prone, take his time, and pick a clear lane for a shot on what we called "the spotted bull" due to his rumpled coat. He says the hit looked good. It's all happening just how we'd drawn it up.


We optimistically slap high-fives. Now for the fun part.


Elk tracks in deep snow with red blood spots, showing a rough winter trail; tip of a boot visible at lower right.

We give it a half hour before snaking our way up – the three elk disappeared over the hilltop back into the dark timber, but we don't want to rush. Near the top we locate the tracks and find fresh, bright-red blood soaking the snow. I'm already thinking about the work ahead: quartering and packing the meat back to camp. It's going to be a long night, but at least we still have a couple hours of daylight, and there's three of us – we'll make it work. One bull down on the first full day – that means I have another five left to fill my tag.


But it doesn't quite go like that. We follow the sign up over the top, then down into a steep, thickly tangled, snow-covered mess. I've heard places described as hell holes before and this one could be a poster child for the concept. I'm sweating and straining for breath going downhill. After nearly a mile and a half we run out of blood, and daylight is fading fast. We're now three miles and several ridges from camp and decide to call it for the night rather than push farther and risk bumping him.


Two hunters with backpacks walk through a snowy pine forest at dusk, following tracks under a blue sky.

We click on headlamps and start back. The walk is solemn and quiet; each lost in our own thoughts. The disappointment is heavy but hangs heaviest on Blake. It's the worst-case scenario. As hunters we always hope for a quick kill or a clean miss; not the haunting pit in your gut that comes from wounding and not recovering an animal. Each moment of the day plays over and over in our heads. Where was the hit? What went wrong? What could we have done differently? Will we find this bull?


Back at camp we stoke the stove, eat our meals, and talk it through. Everything seemed right. Maybe a liver shot? Blake was a little concerned about hitting shoulder, so maybe he hit back a little too far for lungs? To me the blood was too bright for a liver hit but some of it adds up. There wasn't a lot of blood – mostly small dots in the tracks as we went along. And while a liver shot is always fatal, a liver-hit animal can go a long way before finally bedding, especially if they are being pushed. We'll let things settle overnight, go back in daylight, and pick up where we left off. It's difficult to sleep, but despite the circumstances we're still optimistic.


Lit beige tipi at night beneath a starry blue sky, with dark pine silhouettes around a quiet forest campsite.

We start out at daylight, retracing our steps back to last blood, crossing the prints of a lone wolf along the way. From here things get a bit tangled. Without blood it's difficult to discern our bull's tracks from the others mixed in.


We follow one set up the side of the ridge and then circle around. It doesn't seem right. Back to the beginning we follow another set down and to the east for miles before backtracking. Another set runs a mile or so to a bed that shows no sign of blood. We cross it off. The last set leads down deep into the bottom and through a small meadow peppered with hoofmarks and old beds. No bull. We grid-

search the backside, climbing over and ducking under blowdowns and pushing through the thickest of cover, exhausting every possibility. Nothing. If this bull did expire it wasn't here, and our best guess now is that the shot wasn't fatal. But we had to be sure.

Hand in camouflage sleeve and ring beside wolf prints in packed snow, with pine needles scattered around.

Blake tears his tag, acknowledging that, for him, this is the end of the hunt.


Back to the truck in the dark we've packed everything out. 12 up and down-hill miles later my feet are swollen and blistered, my legs are cut and bruised, my shoulders ache and burn – I'm worn down, hungry, and sweat covered. It's easy, in this moment, to feel defeated. To call it quits – throw in the towel. But we still have four days and one tag in our pocket; we'll keep pushing.


That night we drive back to Kyle's house for a proper meal, warm showers, and soft beds. A much-needed pick-me-up. From here on out it will be day hunts in some of the Plan B, C, and D locations.


For the next three days we cover country. Donning waders to cross rivers, navigating boulder fields and marshes, burns and meadows. Over saddles and up steep slopes. But never locate another bull that gives us an opportunity.


Two hunters in camouflage climb up an old burned hillside with yellow grass

Just like that we're down to the last morning. Blake elects to sleep in while Kyle and I attempt a full Hail Mary - slow stalking through dark timber where earlier in the year he bumped a 5x5. We park the truck and nudge our way up, eyes fixed ahead. Searching. Rifle in hand.


Through the dark timber we cross several heavy game trails, shredded trees, and old beds. Up, and up, and up we go, until we finally run out of real estate. We pause, exchange "there's still a chance," glances then reverse course, altering our route slightly, and zigzag back down. On the edge of a thick gully, we hear a crash and catch a brief glimpse of blonde and antler through the tangle. It all happens so fast. I shoulder the gun but never find him in the crosshairs.


Back at the truck, I unload the Weatherby, snap it securely in its case, and take in a deep breath of pine-scented air, and a 360-degree view of the big sky that gives this place its name. Many of my non-hunting or angling friends wonder how it's possible to fail so many times and still remain optimistic. Why I keep going back. Trying again. Spending the time and money and energy with nothing to show for it. How is that fun? How does it even make sense?


The Dalai Lama once said “Optimism doesn't mean that you are blind to the reality of the situation. It means that you remain motivated to seek a solution to whatever problems arise.” And I suppose that's what it is.


Optimism keeps me motivated to figure things out. To learn from my mistakes. To get better.


It's what forces me to focus on the moment in front. To push for the next bend in the river, and the next rise on the hill. To fish all the way to the takeout and stay in the treestand until the last of the light drains from the sky. It's the reason I keep buying points, applying for tags, and hefting heavy packs in the off months.


There's little sweetness in success without failure first. That is optimism, and there may be no better teacher of it than chasing elk through public-land mountains with a pack on your back and a gun in your hand.


A snow-covered boulder field in the mountains with a bright blue sky and clouds.

I'm in the aisle seat on our flight home. Blake is sleeping by the window with his headphones on. I scroll through the pictures on my phone, remembering the ups and downs of the week. The rugged beauty of the places we explored, and the effort it took to get there. I remember the big bull in the glass and recall the pounding of my heart. I conjure the smell of the place and the blue of the sky. I think about grandchildren I hope to soon share all of this with, and smile.


In two days I'll head to northern Michigan for my annual deer camp. The weather looks like it's going to cooperate.


I'm optimistic.

Comments


​

​

Allen fly fishing at night
  • LinkedIn - Grey Circle
  • Facebook - Grey Circle
  • Instagram - Grey Circle

About Me

Hi, I’m Allen, a husband and father of two adult sons who frequently out hunt, out hike, and out fish me. 

 

By day I run an advertising agency located in my home state of Michigan where I enjoy chasing whitetail, trout, and birds. Beyond Michigan you'll often find me roaming the backcountry of Montana, Colorado, Idaho, or Wyoming. 

 

I was a founding member and co-chair of the Michigan Chapter of Backcountry Hunters and Anglers and currently serve as Vice President for Pere Marquette Trout Unlimited. I'm an active member of the Outdoor Writers Association of America, the Association of Great Lakes Outdoor Writers, and the Michigan Outdoor Writers Association.

​

For several years I served as an Editor at Large and regular contributor to Strung Sporting Journal and penned a quarterly feature for Michigan Out-of-Doors Magazine. Additionally, my byline has appeared in Gray's Sporting Journal, The Drake, Fly Fisher, Fly Fusion, California Fly Fisher, Upland Almanac, the Tom Beckbe Field Journal, American Field Sportsman's Journal, Solace, MDF Magazine, Bugle, and Backcountry Journal.  

 

You can find my first book, Outside in Shorts – an award-winning collection of 29 short essays – here, and my newest book, For Everything There is a Season, here.​​

​

Drop me a note at allen@stevensinc.com

bottom of page